How should Canadian house prices be cooled off?

An overview of would-be fixes

(Photo: C.J. Burton)

(Photo: C.J. Burton)

The Energizer Bunny marching through the Canadian housing market isn’t banging its drum so hard these days. But it “keeps going and going” in places like Vancouver and Toronto, so regulators are mulling over a further tightening of mortgage rules in Canada.

But as Quebec Finance Minister Nicolas Marceau recently suggested, it may be better to target just the overheated parts of Canada this time around. Elsewhere, house sales and prices are coming off the boil. Clamping down across the board would do more harm than good in their case.

Marceau didn’t indicate what the regional policies could be, so let’s try to connect the dots to see what they might look like—and if they are feasible.

It appears there is no real requirement for amortization periods and other mortgage rules to be the same in every province or city. “I am not aware of any legal reason why mortgage requirements need to be uniform across Canada,” says Ian Lee, a professor at Carleton University. “If you want to get serious about controlling debt and house prices, double the down payment requirement on CMHC-insured mortgages in the overheated areas, or tie it to the size of the mortgage issued.”

But with the high levels of government intervention in housing through CMHC and other channels, “there is an expectation that the rules need to be the same from coast to coast—just like Canada Post charges the same rate for stamps,” Lee explains. “There would likely have to be less government involvement for risk to be calibrated more accurately in the housing market.”

Another regional solution could be to tweak zoning regulations. Relaxing land-use restrictions in some areas would allow more land to come onto the market and dampen price increases, suggests Don Campbell, author of several books on Canadian real estate and founder of the Real Estate Investment Network. Problem is, land-use restrictions are usually enacted for valid reasons such as protecting the environment, reducing urban sprawl and preserving agricultural land. “Tinkering with them would provoke a political backlash, making it unlikely such initiatives would be pursued,” Campbell says.

Yet another solution could be for municipal or provincial governments to use their taxation power. “Doubling rates for land-transfer taxes would likely cool the local housing market,” Campbell predicts. “But this hike would be political suicide and unlikely to happen.”

For editor Robert McLister, the “downsides outweigh the benefits” when it comes to regional policies. For one thing, if an area like Toronto had more restrictive rules, we “might see mini-bubbles form on the fringes of the area.” It would “also breed social concerns over urban sprawl, excessive commuting times and greater pollution.” In short, regional policies appear to be politically unacceptable and have unwanted side effects, according to experts in the field. Not to be overlooked either is the inducement to black markets as people try to circumvent regional restrictions.

Attempts to dampen the housing market are perhaps unnecessary at this point, anyway. According to data in the Department of Finance’s Budget 2014 document, annual growth in mortgage credit has slowed substantially, and is now way below the average of the last two decades. “This suggests that homebuyers are purchasing homes with larger down payments and that existing homeowners are taking advantage of low interest rates to pay off their mortgages at a faster rate,” the budget says. When Canadians have higher equity stakes in their homes, it imparts more stability to the market.

Get our daily briefing on innovation, leadership, technology & the economy.
Weekdays at 6 AM ET. Learn More »

9 comments on “How should Canadian house prices be cooled off?

  1. The reason why mortgages are uniform is because of mortgage backed securities guaranteed by the government of Canada. All mortgages issued within a certain timeframe are bundled with no regional variation. the risk for the security is assumed by the Federal taxpayer averaged over the entire Canadian market pool. We do not have Toronto or Vancouver securities. The bundling is facilitated by our relatively homogenized product across the country. We do not have the US’s Jumbo tranches or sub-prime tranches. So there is no risk-weighting across regions or sectors. If we do not offer a homogenized mortgage then the securities will have to be separated to allow for tranched risk assessments by purchasers.

  2. How many times does it take failure, if not catastrophe, to prove Governments shouldn’t intervene in markets to equalise outcomes (or even worse, pick winners and losers). The least economically developed areas will always be hardest hit in a downturn, and share less in an upturn. There are many reasons why they may be disadvantaged, but having a high tax regime (hello Quebec) is first among them. Rather than look for ways to rig the rules to benefit them, Provincial and Municipal governments would be better on focusing on ways to build growth, and therefore demand. Demand is the ultimate mattress for if not a soft landing, then a quicker recovery.

  3. The new rules in Ontario are requiring larger down payments on second homes and have had a large impact on real estate markets in cottage country and tourist towns. For example the Collingwood Real Estate Market and surrounding areas saw a large decline in sales when the new rules were released. It shows you that government rules can change things quickly and not always for the better.

  4. A great time Saturday night. We surprised my parents and they were thriled when they got there..Thank you! I was told by the photo booth person that photos would be online. Where are they?

  5. I guess I should fill something out when I’m here visiting. Thanks for putting up wonderful stuff. It’s asking to get a web internet site here although I am posting this, so here’s one which I had been just checking out. Consider care.

  6. Oh and I’m not a Liverpool or Chelsea supporter, nevertheless the way the Liverpool fans were still singing You’ll Never Walk alone when their team was losing and the game was almost finished was beautiful. Big respect.

  7. Hi Kes,If the challenge is really a username/password issue and you are not able to log in then I am not sure what’s wrong. I tested it a second ago and it seemed to be working fine. Could you check once again and see if it’s ok now?