Will new file-sharing lawsuits make headway in Canada? Probably not

But Voltage Pictures is already trying.


(Photo: John Foxx/Getty)

Well, that didn’t take long: Hollywood has come barging into Canada with file-sharing lawsuits aimed at people who may or may not have downloaded movies over BitTorrent, according to internet service provider TekSavvy.

The indie ISP reports that it has been served with a request for customer information by Voltage Pictures, the Los Angeles-based producer of The Hurt Locker. The company is seeking the release of the identities of 2,000 customers so that it can go ahead and sue them under the new copyright laws that recently came into force.

As copyright expert Michael Geist writes, the next step will involve a court hearing next week where a judge will determine whether TekSavvy will have to release the info. The ISP, to its credit, is resisting doing so. If the court does indeed force the company to divulge names, Voltage is expected to forge ahead with the lawsuits or offer settlements to alleged infringers.

The development is interesting for several reasons. On the one hand, as both TekSavvy head Marc Gaudrault and my Maclean’s colleague Jesse Brown point out, lawsuits against individuals seem to go against what the government intended with its copyright modernization. As Heritage Minister James Moore has insisted, “it’s not industry’s business to go out there and sue their customers.”

It looks like the good minister should be eating his words right about now.

But more poignantly, in the United States this sort of thing is frowned upon. Some judges have pulled no punches in cases where plaintiffs have offered settlements to defendants, essentially branding them as copyright trolls. As Judge Otis D. Wright in the Central District of California put it, “The federal courts are not cogs in a plaintiff’s copyright-enforcement business model. The Court will not idly watch what is essentially an extortion scheme, for a case that plaintiff has no intention of bringing to trial.”

Extortion indeed. Earlier this summer, a group of sue-ees decided to strike back with a class-action lawsuit against porn companies who were trolling for similar settlements.

The Voltage lawsuits may actually be a good thing for Canada. With any luck, some of them will actually go to trial, in which case the court can determine appropriate damages. The new copyright laws allow penalties for non-commercial infringement of between $100 and $5,000. Any sane judge is likely to arrive at one conclusion—that $100 is more than appropriate—in which case Hollywood can buzz off because such cases won’t be worth anyone’s time.

Get our daily briefing on innovation, leadership, technology & the economy.
Weekdays at 6 AM ET. Learn More »

4 comments on “Will new file-sharing lawsuits make headway in Canada? Probably not

  1. hopefully the Canadian gov’t does not allow citizens to be sued or harassed over downloading content which is openly and freely available on the net. I can see going after folks who profit by pirating and selling………………….but hey,get off the “little guys” back. Gawd knows how expensive it is to go to the theatres these days,plus having to endure the multitude of commercials prior to screening. .

  2. They certainly can try to recover what they feel they are owed in lost revenues but there has to be a limit on the actual amount an individual who has been downloading copyrighted material for personal use and not commercial use should pay.
    The way they have been going about this is all wrong – better to work out something , and ask a modest amount that they would probably get instead of some ridiculous amount they will never see.

  3. Stephen: I’m interested in your Letters in the Mail subscription. I am a high college English teacher, and that i assumed this could possibly be a very good way to acquire my students to write responding on the letters. Nonetheless, I have to be certain that the topics in the letters will likely be appropriate for my students 9, 10, and 11th graders. Will you please comment on what the topics will be in general? Thanks.