RALEIGH, N.C. – A North Carolina judge on Friday denied Duke Energy’s motion seeking to shield records related to groundwater pollution leaching from 33 coal ash dumps in the state while a separate federal criminal investigation is ongoing.
Superior Court Judge Paul Ridgeway’s ruling came after Duke defence lawyer Jim Cooney scaled back the company’s request to restrict access to documents in a civil case filed last year by state regulators over environmental violations.
Duke had initially argued potential public disclosure of company documents handed over through the discovery process could taint the criminal probe. A federal grand jury in Raleigh has issued at least 23 subpoenas to state environmental officials and Duke following a Feb. 2 coal ash spill that coated 70 miles of the Dan River in toxic grey sludge.
A coalition of environmental groups has intervened in the state’s case against Duke. Cooney expressed concern that lawyers for those private groups might file sensitive company documents as exhibits in court briefs or introduce them as evidence in open court hearings, thereby making them available to the media.
Cooney asked Ridgeway to approve a “prophylactic” order to seal the records and prevent news stories that might present the company in an unfavourable light and potentially influence members of the grand jury.
“Duke intends to fully co-operate with the government of the United States in this investigation because we haven’t violated any laws,” Cooney said. “We want a fair, unbiased and impartial grand jury investigation.”
Frank Holleman, a lawyer for the Southern Environmental Law Center, told the judge there was no legal justification for limiting the typical public disclosure of information in the civil case just because Duke is also the target of a criminal probe.
Holleman pointed out that his group had filed a motion seeking documents from Duke in August and that the company had failed to yet hand over any. He said the company’s latest courtroom manoeuvring was just another attempt to delay the case.
“What he wants to do is put a blanket over these documents … as if they somehow get stamped Top Secret grand jury materials,” Holleman said, referring to Cooney. “There is absolutely no reason the public should not be aware of information that comes up in this case.”
Ruling from the bench, the judge agreed with Holleman to keep the documents public. But Ridgeway also said Duke could later seek to seal some of the records as trade secrets on a case-by-case basis if they could show him such a designation was justified.
Ridgeway also approved a request from the N.C. Department of Environment and Natural Resources to withdraw an earlier proposed settlement that would have allowed Duke to settle environmental violations at ash dumps near Charlotte and Fayetteville. In the wake of the Dan River spill, the agency now says it intends to take Duke to court.
Follow Associated Press writer Michael Biesecker at Twitter.com/mbieseck